Skip to main content

'I am The Truth'

Truth has always been subjected to subjectivism and denied any objectivity! This ofcourse pleases those who set standards for what is right and what is wrong and truth is judged according to these standards. We are thrown aback with a deluge of  lies so that standards are inverted and lie becomes truth and truth lie. This is surely not a modern phenomenon we already have a metaphor from the 9th century in the form of Mansur Al-Hallaj. Even if most people do not know the whole story of his trial, imprisonment and subsequent execution, we all know he stood up for truth. He is a symbol of truth. Hussain Ibn Ali before him in the 7th century stood up in a similar way with a handful of people by his side to show that truth was objectively true and there was no such thing as a subjective truth. Hundreds, thousands, millions or a billion people believeing in one thing which is not true does not make it 'their way of looking at things' and 'true for them' and subjectively true.
Having said that there are problems in proving to anyone the objectivity of truth. This world and everything we see in it is a reflection of our imagination and since that imagination is created, even before we are born, by number of factors, it is very hard to find arguments for truth. It is much easier on the other hand to argue about the subjectivity of truth. In this regard what is different from 7th and 9th century in our 21st century is this explosion of media and communication. Imagination is created from the earliest moments even in unborn children in their mother's wombs who are exposed through their mother's thoughts influenced by television and other means and later while they are put in front of televisions to watch 'children programmes' to keep out of their parents way for a 'while'. How will these kids distinguish between right and wrong when their conscience is handed on a platter to be molded or worst, overwritten by the media. We become puppets in the hands of media barons. Repitition of lies or half truths become the reality and truth and that which is not said often enough or not said at all becomes a lie. In a globalized world where humans cannot cross borders except after stringent checks information floats easily through porous borders and the world is made to see one version of what truth must look like! This becomes the standard and since our hearts and minds are already influenced we absorb this standard willingly. We see things as black or white, either on x-axis or y-axis never as grey or on z-axis. We choose from set of options given to us and never see that there might be other options not given in that list.
I think we need to look for truth not outside but inside us and not be afraid of sounding foolish by saying so openly. 10 million references on google or a million fans on facebook does not make something which is not true true, true?

Comments

Anonymous said…
This is very interesting and true as well. We have long forgotten about what is original and genuine. Even the very own and personal thoughts would have been inculcated in us through some mean that consiously we are unaware of. But interestingly going through your third blog, I see that even you have not been able to free from yourself from the dictates of all these sources and they also have been able to make your impressions :)
9 April 2011 at 07:43
مایون said…
Thank you for your comments. If you do go beyond the third post you might be able to see in some of the other ones that it looks at the other side that of the 'modern', 'liberal' and 'enlightened' approach and finds many things amiss in that. I do consent, though you haven't brought it up' that much of what I have written is a part of the discourse, a reaction to what is going on. That, i think, is inescapable and also needed to look at how we should be looking at the same things. The play is the same but the parts have nuanced characterization.
9 April 2011 at 13:17
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Captains!

Haven't written in a while and those following my blog would know by now that whenever something disturbing on the world scene happens, I stop writing. Its an irony because usually writers provide solace through their writings while I, lose all power of expression when I am disturbed. And then what is there to write? Follow any newspaper from around the world and there is only one message that you get: Pakistan is rapidly slipping into an abyss! I was born in the 70s and have grown up in the 90s, I have vague recollection of the 80s even though I was not old enough to understand what life under Zia's martial law was like but I have seen relay race of power between Benazir and Nawaz Sharif in the 90s but never in our history have we been so unsafe. Where every person big or small, significant or otherwise, powerful or weak, rich or poor is exposed equally to this invisible enemy. Call it what you might, Taliban, extremist, jihadi, Al Qaeda, seperatist, a murderer by any name is ...
3 comments
Read more

Snapshots

Naseem, is a six year old girl. When I met her she was sitting on the charpoi with her mother and constantly clapping but without any mirth. Her hair was cut almost to her scalp. I was told that she was a miracle child, she had been suffering from severe acute malnutrition and her family and relatives had almost given up hope that she would survive but she had proven all stats wrong and was sitting right in front of us. Physically, she was on the mend but her mental growth had been irreversibly stunted. She did not respond to any movement, any gesture or sound, her mind was somewhere else... A little boy, hardly seven, sitting on the curbside on an otherwise busy junction but at 0100AM he seemed so out of place on that dark, deserted road. As we stopped at the traffic signal, on the road perpendicular to where he was sitting, my attention was drawn to his posture. His slumped back was towards me and as I watched, two cars stopped on the lanes furthest from him. He made an ...
2 comments
Read more

A classic case of putting your foot in your mouth!

Its been a couple of days since Imran Khan and Reham Khan announced their separation and decision to divorce. Nothing out of the ordinary there, as the decision to marry was also theirs, except maybe the timing of the announcement which coincided with the local bodies elections and may have had an impact but thats something which would be very difficult to gauge. What I do find quite extraordinary and almost bordering on incredulous is the amazing audacity of PTI supporters to present this break up as a result of some sort of principled stand by Mr. Khan. The idea being that Ms. Khan wanted to play a role in party politics and Mr. Khan could not bring himself to allow this so he had to sacrifice his marriage for his principled stand! How utterly outrageous is this! This is not principled stance but rather immaturity and shortsightedness. These two got into this relationship out of probably love and, I would assume, mutual admiration and respect. It was definitely not an 'arranged...
1 comment
Read more